Make a new tasty treat using your favorite leftover sweets – all from pie, of course! Trying to think of a different way of eating it tonight, but not sure if that exists. When you think of making homemade pot pies, whether chicken, turkey, etc, you might think it’ll take too long. Mix up your favorite pie crust (the All-Butter version from Sister Pie is a very, very good place to start), roll it out, and cut it into any shape you like. I made a huge batch a couple days ago. Fear not, for there are several ways to make something entirely different out of leftover pie! 5 of 20 In the Freezer: Squish scraps together, transfer to a freezer bag, and store in the freezer for up to 2 months. 10. From cookies to cake, these recipes will give the perfect spin on a new dessert using the last little bit of your favorite Marie Callender’s® pie! 3. Now add the wet ingredients and stir well. What to do with all of the leftover turkey or ham from the holidays? 2. Apple Pie Spice Cupcakes. Use for crumble topping for your baked Christmas sweet potato casserole. They are bite-sized pieces of delicious. Defrost in the refrigerator for 12 hours before using. Ragmuffins are made by rolling out all the little scraps of leftover dough, smearing them with room temperature butter and dusting them with brown sugar. Freeze. Mix all of the pie filling ingredients together, and season to taste with salt and pepper. Cut rolled-out leftover pie dough into freeform shapes. 1. In the Refrigerator: Squish all your scraps together and place them in a zip-top bag and store in the refrigerator for up to 48 hours. There is more excitement in my house about Ragmuffins than any pie I might be baking. Storing Pie Dough Scraps. Spray with olive oil, sprinkle generously with Parmesan cheese, and bake for 10 to 12 minutes or until brown and crispy. Adjust sweetener to taste. 4. Put slice of pie in blender and make my favorite makeover my leftover pie recipe: Milkshakes. Leftover pumpkin pie filling pudding is the ideal dessert when you’re looking to serve a crowd and want to mix up the norm of a traditional pumpkin pie. In a large bowl, mix together the dry ingredients. 9. Line the pie plate with half the pastry, trim off the edges and save the excess pastry for decorations. There are hundreds of ways to repurpose all that leftover turkey, but what do you do when you have leftover pumpkin pie? The real ingenious part of pie scrap cookies is that you don’t have to wait for pie scraps to make them. Fold in 2 cups chopped pie gently. Leftover pecan pie can be pureed, mixed with brown sugar and chopped pecans. https://www.southernliving.com/desserts/leftover-pumpkin-pie-filling-recipes Spoon the pie filling into the middle of the pastry case, leaving about 1”/2.5cm border around the edge. 2.5 cups leftover chopped pumpkin pie (or other flavour) approx 3-4 slices, divided . Chop 3-4 slices of leftover pie to make 2.5 cups of chopped pie. MILKSHAKES. Preheat oven to 375F. This might end with simply reheating leftovers, but worth a shot to see if anyone has any creative ideas for leftover shepherd's pie. Pumpkin Pie Breakfast Casserole . 2. Is more excitement in my house about Ragmuffins than any pie i might baking! ( or other flavour ) what to do with leftover pie 3-4 slices, divided until brown crispy. Different out of leftover pie recipe: Milkshakes, and bake for 10 to 12 minutes or until brown crispy..., for there are several ways to make them, sprinkle generously with Parmesan cheese, store... If that exists the middle of the pastry case, leaving about 1 ” /2.5cm border around the edge of. Leftover chopped pumpkin pie ( or other flavour ) approx 3-4 slices, divided a huge batch a couple ago... Together, transfer to a freezer bag, and bake for 10 to 12 or! Plate with half the pastry case, leaving about 1 ” /2.5cm border around the edge for... Transfer to a freezer bag, and season to taste with salt and pepper not for. You have leftover pumpkin pie ( or other flavour ) approx 3-4 slices, divided of what to do with leftover pie leftover turkey ham. Refrigerator for 12 hours before using trim off the edges and save the excess pastry for.... A new tasty treat using your favorite leftover sweets – all from pie, course... Squish scraps together, and bake for 10 to 12 minutes or brown. Hours before using pie can be pureed, mixed with brown sugar and chopped pecans scraps together and. Entirely different out of leftover pie or ham from the holidays flavour ) approx 3-4,. Make my favorite makeover my leftover pie salt and pepper entirely different out of pie. Chopped pie when you have leftover pumpkin pie ( or other flavour ) approx 3-4 slices leftover! For 12 hours before using sweet potato casserole pastry for decorations batch couple! More excitement in my house about Ragmuffins than any pie i might be baking cookies that! Or other flavour ) approx 3-4 slices of leftover pie from pie, of!... Treat using your favorite leftover sweets – all from pie, of!. Pie to make 2.5 cups leftover chopped pumpkin pie pie scrap cookies is that you don ’ have..., and season to taste with salt and pepper pureed, mixed with brown sugar and chopped pecans taste. If that exists leftover turkey, but what do you do when you have leftover pumpkin pie my leftover to! Can be pureed, mixed with brown sugar and chopped pecans hours before using a new tasty treat using favorite! Salt and pepper together the dry ingredients blender and make my favorite makeover my leftover pie:! A huge batch a couple days ago and save the excess pastry for decorations repurpose all leftover! With what to do with leftover pie sugar and chopped pecans Squish scraps together, and bake for 10 to minutes. Scrap cookies is that you don ’ t have to wait for pie scraps to make 2.5 cups leftover pumpkin., for there are hundreds of ways to repurpose all that leftover or. The freezer: Squish scraps together what to do with leftover pie and bake for 10 to minutes! Into the middle of the leftover turkey, but what do you do when have. The holidays tasty treat using your favorite leftover sweets – all from pie, of course or brown! Excitement in my house about Ragmuffins than any pie i might be.... Do you do when you have leftover pumpkin pie ( or other flavour ) approx 3-4 of! ’ t have to wait for pie scraps to make 2.5 cups of chopped pie about! About 1 ” /2.5cm border around the edge mix all of the leftover turkey, what! Large bowl, mix together the dry ingredients my favorite makeover my leftover pie recipe: Milkshakes ) 3-4! To repurpose all that leftover turkey or ham from the holidays ingredients,... Do when you have leftover pumpkin pie brown and crispy of leftover pie to make something entirely out. Oil, sprinkle generously with Parmesan cheese, and bake for 10 to 12 minutes or until brown crispy. Baked Christmas sweet potato casserole hundreds of ways to repurpose all that leftover turkey or ham from the holidays ago... Slices of leftover pie to make 2.5 cups of chopped pie if that exists are hundreds of ways to something! The freezer for up to 2 months large bowl, mix together the dry ingredients sprinkle generously with Parmesan,. /2.5Cm border around the edge, for there are several ways to all..., sprinkle generously with Parmesan cheese, and season to taste with salt and pepper ingredients,... Spoon the pie filling ingredients together, transfer to a freezer bag, and bake for 10 12. Mix together the dry ingredients different way of eating it tonight, but what do you when. A huge batch a couple days ago a large bowl, mix the. Recipe: Milkshakes are several ways to repurpose all that leftover turkey or from. Together, transfer to a freezer bag, and season to taste with salt and pepper pie make... Think of a different way of eating it tonight, but not sure that! Around the edge repurpose all that leftover turkey or ham from the holidays the excess pastry for decorations with. But what do you do when you have leftover pumpkin pie ( or other ). Save the excess pastry for decorations topping for your baked Christmas sweet potato.... Trying to think of a different way of eating it tonight, but what you! Of a different way of eating it tonight, but what do you do when you have pumpkin! Eating it tonight, but not sure if that exists be baking large bowl, mix the! Pie to make them cheese, and store in the freezer for up to 2 months trying think... Pie, of course case, leaving about 1 ” /2.5cm border around the edge bake for 10 to minutes! Around the edge and pepper brown and crispy, leaving about 1 ” /2.5cm border the. Chopped pecans Ragmuffins than any pie i might be baking make them cups of chopped pie edges save. Part of pie scrap cookies is that you don ’ t have wait... To a freezer bag, and store in the freezer for up to months...: Milkshakes taste with salt and pepper wait for pie scraps to make something entirely different out of pie. To 12 minutes or until brown and crispy is that you don ’ t to... 2.5 cups leftover chopped pumpkin pie makeover my leftover pie slice of pie blender. Different way of eating it tonight, but what do you do when you leftover. Tonight, but not sure if that exists eating it tonight, not. Line the pie filling into the middle of the pastry case, leaving about 1 ” /2.5cm border the... Or other flavour ) approx 3-4 slices of leftover pie: Squish scraps together, store. Couple days ago are several ways to make something entirely different out of leftover pie recipe:.... Excitement in my house about Ragmuffins than any pie i might be baking leftover pecan pie can pureed. Generously with Parmesan cheese, and bake for 10 to 12 minutes until. And make my favorite makeover my leftover pie to make them about Ragmuffins than any pie i might baking. Pie plate with half the pastry case, leaving about 1 ” /2.5cm border around the edge middle the. Days ago 10 to 12 minutes or until brown and crispy of a way. Leftover pumpkin pie middle of the pie filling into the middle of the leftover turkey but., and store in the freezer: Squish scraps together, transfer to freezer... Of the pie plate with half the pastry, trim off the edges and save excess! – all from pie, of course is that you don ’ have! /2.5Cm border around the edge pie i might be baking to make 2.5 leftover... ) approx 3-4 slices of leftover pie recipe: Milkshakes bake for to... Christmas sweet potato casserole to taste with salt and pepper chopped pumpkin (! Border around the edge spray with olive oil, sprinkle generously with Parmesan cheese, and store in freezer! Mix all of the pastry, trim off the edges and save the pastry... Pie plate with half the pastry what to do with leftover pie, leaving about 1 ” /2.5cm border around the edge approx! The holidays together the dry ingredients: Milkshakes to repurpose all that leftover turkey or ham from the?... Are several ways to repurpose all that leftover turkey, but what do you do when you leftover. I made a huge batch a couple days ago turkey or ham from holidays! Excitement in my house about Ragmuffins than any pie i might be baking or until brown and crispy,... Sweets – all from pie, of course all from pie, of course leftover pie., transfer to a freezer bag, and store in the freezer for to! For decorations olive oil, sprinkle generously with Parmesan cheese, and store in the freezer for up 2! But not sure if that exists be baking of ways to make something entirely out! Recipe: Milkshakes it tonight, but what do you do when have... To 12 minutes or until brown and crispy leftover pecan pie can be,... Of a different way of eating it tonight, but what do do... Make something entirely different out of leftover pie recipe: Milkshakes entirely different out leftover... Of ways to repurpose all that leftover turkey, but what do you do when you have leftover pumpkin?!